1. No. 19 on that list is wrong. Vader isn't confirming the kill of Kenobi, he's looking for the body, wondering where it is.

Posted at 9:12PM on Aug 12th 2008 by Bob

2. I guess my top one is when Vader's talking to the bounty hunters, instructing them to capture(i think it was the Millenium Falcon and it's crew. He proceeds:
"I need them alive(looks at Boba Fett)...no disintegrations!"

He might as wel l have said "This means you, Fett!"

Posted at 9:47PM on Aug 12th 2008 by Batzarro

3. Abso-freakin-lutely!

Posted at 6:32PM on Aug 13th 2008 by thegoldfishpool

4. I am your father should be in the top three.

Where is the Duel Between Anakin and Obi-Wan? The opening space battle in Revenge of the Sith?

Posted at 11:23PM on Aug 12th 2008 by Daniel M

5. Since I don't believe that episodes I - III were bad ass (except in their combined effort to sell shit) I must say that this list is decidedly lacking any bad assness

Posted at 7:26AM on Aug 13th 2008 by chris

6. My list would have to be in the thousands long before I got to any "bad-ass" scenes from I thru III. There's a bajillion in New Hope alone. The scorched parents, the first time we see Darth Bad-Ass, blowing up planets, space dog-fights, the moment Luke says he wants to be a Jedi like his father, Han shooting first, blowing up a friggin' death star, the whole fight scene leading up to the DS's demise, "We're all fine here, now. How are you?", sneaking around the tractor beam thingies, Luke swinging across the broken bridge with Lea, the duel between Vader and Obi-Wan, "Run, Luke, run!".... I mean, c'mon.

This is a lame-ass list.

Posted at 8:20AM on Aug 13th 2008 by J, aka J

7. By parents, I meant aunt and uncle of course. Geez, penalty.

Posted at 8:21AM on Aug 13th 2008 by J, aka J

8. Absolute coolest moment: Vader is looking at the Millenium Falcon after its been pulled into the Death Star. Vader says "I sense a presence I haven't felt since...." and then he walks off without finishing the sentence. Let me finish that for you Vader.... since Obi Wan whooped your little whiney BEHIND and left you for dead! HAH, that moment took on such a deeper meaning after Episode III came out.

Posted at 8:22AM on Aug 13th 2008 by Eric

9. ridiculous list. top 5 should have been (in this order):
1-Vader reveals his paternity to Luke
2-Yoda's battle against Dooku
3-Yoda pulling Luke's fighter out of the swamp
4-Han telling Chewie he has to take care of Leia (makes me tear-up EVERY time)
5-Han flies into the asteroid field (gives me goosebumps EVERY time)

the fact that Vader revealing himself to luke as his father isn't even top 10 is just plain stupid and singlehandedly kills this list's credibility.

Posted at 11:45AM on Aug 13th 2008 by peter

10. Though, Han Solo is my favorite character of all time (and Leia is just freaking awesome too) I don't think the most BA of moments is carbonite freezing chamber one. I love that scene, don't get me wrong, makes me shed some tears every time, but man, I agree, in Episode III, the battle against Obi-Wan and Anakin (aka Darth Vader) to me, is the most memorable and most BA moment ever. Every time I watch it..it gives me shivers. It's just..wow. Not just for the physical effects but the mental effects as well. Padawan fighting Master. Best Friend fighting Best Friend. Brother fighting Brother-- it's insanely intense.

I also think, in Episode III, when Darth Vader is in that chamber and being placed in that iconic suit and the helmet slides over his face and you hear him breathe for the first time-- is just as BA as the battle and deserves to be either BA moment one or two.

Posted at 10:13AM on Aug 14th 2008 by Crystal